Welcome to Sue's Little Pizza Shop
**About Sue's Little Pizza Shop**
Nestled in the heart of Ontario, NY, Sue's Little Pizza Shop is a beloved gem known for its authentic New York-style pizza. Locals rave about the thin crust, perfectly balanced sauce, and creative toppings that exemplify pizza perfection. Sue herself fosters a warm, inviting atmosphere, making every customer feel like family. Whether you're indulging in their fantastic pepperoni or savoring their acclaimed wings, each bite speaks to Sue's dedication to quality and service. With friendly staff and unmissable lunch specials, this charming shop transforms casual visits into delightful dining experiences that keep patrons coming back for more.
-
1795 Ridge Rd, Ontario, NY 14519, United States Hotline: +1 315-524-2222
Welcome to Sue's Little Pizza Shop, a hidden gem nestled in the charming town of Ontario, NY. Tucked away on 1795 Ridge Rd, this quaint pizzeria offers a culinary experience that delights both locals and travelers alike. If you're searching for authentic New York-style pizza, look no further than this beloved establishment, where each slice tells a story of passion and dedication.
Sue’s Little Pizza Shop is not just a place to grab a bite; it’s an experience infused with warmth and hospitality. The heart and soul of this shop is none other than Sue herself, who treats every customer like family. Her welcoming demeanor has garnered rave reviews, with patrons noting how she remembers every familiar face and takes the time to engage with them. This personable approach makes the atmosphere truly inviting, leaving a lasting impression on everyone who walks through the door.
Customers rave about the phenomenal pizza served at Sue's. The thin crust is perfectly balanced, providing just the right amount of support for an array of toppings without overwhelming the palate. Jason, a satisfied diner, describes it as "just the right amount of sauce and toppings," highlighting the attention to detail that Sue puts into each dish. Whether you crave classic pepperoni or adventurous specialty slices, you can expect a slice that is cooked to perfection every time.
In addition to their delicious pizza, Sue's Little Pizza Shop serves some of the best wings around. Dave B describes them as "crispy but yet extremely juicy and flavorful," which speaks to the quality you can always expect from this culinary haven. Customers also appreciate the exceptional value offered, particularly the Tuesday deals on specialty slices—at just two slices for six bucks, it’s hard to resist trying something new each week.
Even those who are simply passing through have found their way back to this delightful spot. Many agree that Sue’s offers a slice of authentic New York-style pizza that evokes the spirit of Manhattan—bold, foldable, and utterly satisfying. As Grady notes, “we found them to have many similarities to classic NY style pizza,” and it's this quality that keeps customers returning for more.
So, whether you're a local or just passing through Ontario, make sure to stop by Sue's Little Pizza Shop. With outstanding service, a menu that delights the senses, and a community feel that makes one feel right at home, it’s no wonder patrons can’t wait to return for just one more slice. (Phone: +1 315-524-2222)
This is definitely that little place off the beaten path you have been looking for. Happened to see it on maps and stopped in for a quick lunch while traveling. Pizza was phenomenal! Thin crust, just the right amount of sauce and toppings. The staff was very friendly (I assume the one lady was Sue, she knew every other customer that stopped in). Definitely a local place but my wife and I felt just as welcome to be there as everyone else. Can’t wait to travel back out to Walworth next weekend to get another slice!
Yumm! Yumm! Yumm! From Rochester 1st time eater and as good as the best in the City. When in area will order again, or even just passing thru. Love the pepperoni !!!
Just a bit of shine for this WayCo GEM. Authentic NY style slices, great specialty slices & terrific service. If ur out 104 way, make it a point to stop into Sue’s.
Absolutely the best wings around crispy but yet extremely juicy and very flavorful. Pizza also amazing and very creative. I tell everyone I talk with to try their food. No one has been disappointed.
Can't really make much of a comment about the atmosphere since this was a just pick up order but I can say this was an especially welcoming place. I was behind another customer picking up pizza. I was so impressed that the owner not only knew that customer, but took the time to get updated about how things were in his world! I know many people would find this "inconvenient." I found it charming that she would take the 30 extra seconds to make that person feel special, to feel important to her as a person, not just a customer. Anyway, took our pizzas home and found them to have many similarities to classic NY style pizza, thin crust, not overdone toppings, cooked perfectly, and above all, foldable! We were craving NY style pizza. Can't really get that unless you're on a street corner in Manhattan but this was pretty darn close. I think we just found our new pizza shop.
This is absolutely hands down the best pizza shop in the town of Ontario. Sue takes pride in her food and service to her customers. It's very well priced.
Great lunch spot! Sue’s day Tuesday deal on specialty slices is unmissable, always something new and 2 slices for 6 bucks is a steal!
One bite everybody knows the rules!! ..and as the old adage goes rules were made to be broken! As a pizza snob this place does it for me, its great and I hope they never change.